Oct. 3 issue: Letters/Opinion

North Star Waldorf Academy: Looking ahead with hope

With gratitude for all who have stood beside us, I want to share with the Encinitas community that North Star Waldorf Academy will not appeal to the San Diego County Board of Education at this time. This decision follows careful reflection on our experience petitioning the Encinitas Union School District (EUSD) and on the realities of California’s charter-school climate.

When California adopted the Charter Schools Act in 1992, the aim was clear: expand public-school options, invite innovation, and encourage diverse learning models. For many years, petitioners were evaluated on academic vision, fiscal soundness, and community benefit.

In the past decade, however, new statutes and shifting interpretations have made approval harder. Measures like AB 1505 (2019), intended to strengthen oversight, have too often become tools for delay or denial. Across the state, technicalities and pressure from entrenched interests now dominate what should be a fair, student-centered process.North Star Waldorf Academy was created to meet a need voiced by Encinitas families: a tuition-free, public, Waldorf-inspired school where children learn through creativity, rhythm, and connection to nature. Our goal has always been to complement—not compete with—the excellent programs already in place in EUSD.

Unfortunately, review of our petition was clouded by misconceptions about Waldorf education and resistance to new ideas. Procedural maneuvers overshadowed dialogue, and at hearings, personal attacks replaced curiosity. Even the number of letters supporting our school was misrepresented, with many heartfelt endorsements left uncounted because they were submitted after the agenda had been prepared. It is disheartening to see fear of change or concern for budgets eclipse the shared goal of serving children.

Healthy public education should welcome proven models that meet high standards and serve real community needs. Instead, debates about “competition” and “budget impacts” often prevail, as though families were statistics rather than people seeking the best fit for their kids. True accountability and innovation arise when schools — district and charter alike— earn families’ trust through quality and respect.

After weighing the chances for constructive collaboration, the impact on community relationships, and our wish to focus on building rather than battling, we have chosen to temporarily pause the process of petitioning for charter approval. This is not defeat but an opportunity to learn, strengthen partnerships, and prepare for a time when dialogue is possible.

To every parent, educator, and neighbor who offered support or asked thoughtful questions: thank you. North Star Waldorf Academy remains steadfast in its mission to bring a tuition-free, Waldorf-inspired school—one that embodies beauty, wonder, and rigorous learning—to all who seek it.

Melissa Nilsen, Ph.D.

Lead Petitioner, North Star Waldorf Academy

Letters policy: What’s on your mind?

Letters published in this newspaper express views from readers about community matters. Letters reflect the writers’ opinions and not those of the newspaper staff or publisher. Letters are subject to editing. To share your thoughts in this public forum, email them with your first and last names and city or neighborhood of residence to editor@rsfreview.com.  The deadline is 10 a.m. Friday for consideration of publication in the next week’s paper. The current word limit for letters is about 450 words maximum. Letters without the writer’s name cannot be published. Letters from the same person are limited to one in a 30-day period.